top of page

At the dinner party

7 hours ago
4 min read

I recently attended a dinner party. Nothing pretentious, just a comfortable group of friends getting together to share good times, good food, and good company. All responsibilities were shared; people brought bottles of wine, pre-cooked dishes, and everyone dug in to whatever took their fancy.


Conversation was easy, company relaxed without agenda or judgement. As the desserts were finished and the usual debate of should we have tea, coffee, or cheese next, erupted, someone asked one of the best questions I've ever heard.


"Which literary figure do you most closely identify with?"


On the face of it it seems so innocuous and innocent. Like a conversation prompt from some card game designed to be played in groups. But it isn't the usual sloppy, trite cocktail party ice-breaker. It's asking for a literary figure, not a movie character, or worse, a famous person. It isn't asking for who you like or admire, which produces answers with intangible meaning. Immediately, you have to think a little more about it and know that it's going to elicit higher-brow responses than 'Ironman,' George Clooney,' or 'The Dude!'


Maybe the bumbling member of the group will say Whinnie-the-Pooh, or the one who fancies himself a spy will claim George Smiley, maybe someone will say Bridget Jones. Then people start answering; "Oliver," it fits. "Mr. Darcy," he wishes! "William Thacker," of course, anything that could possible connect him to Julia Roberts. But then someone flaws everyone; "Katniss Everdeen!"


We were a little surprised by how she had so openly answered the question. She has always appeared to be one of the strongest in the group. Someone who always has it 'together.' Rarely complaining about anything, never late, always generous, caring, and always making others comfortable. But she is comparing herself to the one who is shunned within her community, forced into a situation she has no control over, and has to constantly fight to survive. A couple of people who understood the impact of her answer hugged her. We all realized that the question, when answered honestly, truthfully, has a much deeper presence than first appears. The attention and focus of the conversation moved to her; asking how we can help, what she needs, lending shoulders to support and cry on. We promptly forgot the question and that could be answered in such different ways, only one carrying meaningful weight.


I've thought a lot about that question since, and keep returning to "Jude Fawley." The titular character of Thomas Hardy's controversial (for it's time) novel, 'Jude the Obscure.' Thank the gods I don't identify with him due to the loss of child, suicide, or adultery, the reasons why the novel was so violently opposed when first published. But rather for the more subtle storyline that flows throughout the novel. Try has he might, Jude could never quite achieve what he aimed for in life, and ultimately ended exactly where he had started. This storyline has an oppressive feeling of existential disappointment that grows as each of his attempts at betterment fail.


This is why I feel drawn to him. Don't get me wrong, I've achieved a lot in my life so far. I have a loving family, I've seen more of the world than most, I have a job that is interesting enough, and has provided me with good opportunities. All of which I'm very grateful for and recognize my luck. But I don't feel like I've reached the peak of my life yet. Thank heavens I don't live where I used to, that would absolutely be too much. But I don't live where I really want to - yet. There are numerous things in my life I feel disappointed about; missed opportunities, opportunities that, in hindsight, should have been avoided. It all boils down to regrets and never quite getting to the path that lead me to where I ultimately want to be, in the timeframe that I was hoping.


Regrets, as we all know, are pointless ruminations that achieve little other than fueling depression and resentment. Neither helpful nor healthy. But regrets are present in many people's lives and can be hard to resolve. I don't want to spoil the novel for anyone, but I haven't yet reached my limit or my end; there is still plenty of time for me to live exactly where my soul should be. Unlike Jude, I have an incredibly loving and supporting partner. I should find more things between then and now, with joy, comfort and happiness. Always being able to hold on, and look forward, to the moment when I do end up where I should.


Now, dear reader, can you be honest with yourself, and brave enough, to give a real answer to the question? Maybe it will strengthen bonds, inspire change, give strength, or just promote discussion to while away enough time until Chris brings out his infamous cheeseboard! Whatever the outcome, realize the question has more power behind it than first appears. Use it carefully.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Dulce et Decorum Est

Bent double, like old beggars under sacks, Knock-kneed, coughing like hags, we cursed through sludge, Till on the haunting flares we turned our backs, And towards our distant rest began to trudge. Men

 
 
 
Autumnus

‘Tis the day after the equinox. The solstice has long since passed and the seasons continue their inexorable march. The harvest is complete, the festivities echoing on the wind. The airs are lighte

 
 
 
Sublimation

Placing the warm cup on my desk, I sit back exhaling, deeply. I’ve made another dark elixir of coffee. A daily vise so steeped in a history of extortion, it’s hard to believe such tastes and pleasur

 
 
 

Comments


Drop Me a Line, Let Me Know What You Think

Thanks for submitting!

musingsofalostsoul © 2023 by Train of Thoughts. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page